April 9, 2019

The Best Spice Substitute for Indian Spices

Post by Admin

Don’t let the lack of the right spices stop you from making your favourite Indian curry. Use the right spice substitute instead.

To help me run the website,this post contains affiliate links at no cost to you. Read the full disclosure here.

When it comes to cooking any regional cuisine the right ingredient is what makes a dish authentic. But what if you are unable to get those ingredients? Is there no way to make that lovely Rogan Josh recipe?!!

Do you skip making a dish after going through the list of ingredients just because you don’t have it?

Do you ever wonder what the possible spice substitute would be in case your nearest supermarket does not stock them?

The good thing about working with spices is that they are not always a MUST have ingredient. There is a way around it, yet maintaining authenticity.

Let’s find out:

Why is it easy to substitute Indian spices with other ingredients 
How to find the best alternative spice substitute
What is the right amount of substitute to be used without compromising on taste?
A comprehensive chart of best alternative spice substitute for popular Indian Spices

How to Substitute Spices Used in Indian Cuisine

It is given that the base of Indian cuisine is the use of spices. After all, can it be an Indian curry without cumin powder, coriander powder or turmeric?

Would you not then make a curry because you don’t have one of the spices listed or may be intolerant to a spice or simply dislike a particular strong spice?

The average Indian dishes have a minimum of 7-9 ingredients out of which 3-4 may be just spices.

Given that there are different ingredients that go to make an Indian dish, it effectively gives you the flexibility to use alternative spices.

This can only be possible if the ingredient, in this case, the spice to be substituted is not the key or the main element of the dish such as pepper for making pepper chicken or mustard for a mustard-based gravy.

As long as the spice substitute has some of the characteristic elements of the listed spice it is absolutely safe to either alternate the spices or omit them completely from the dish.

It is, however, important to note that few spices have a characteristic flavour profile which may be a challenge to replicate. In this case, the dish will tend to lose a degree of its authenticity.

What is The Right Amount of Spice Substitute That Should be Used?

Although I am stating that you have the option of going for an alternative substitute for the spice, but should you be replacing the exact amount?

This question is a bit tricky to answer since there are many factors that depend on what should be the correct replaced amount.

Few things to consider when it comes to looking for a spice substitute are:

1. The type of spice substitute

Not all spices have the same level of taste or flavourSome spices have a stronger flavour profile compared to others.  If your chosen substitute is stronger to the actual spice then you will need to use that in less quantity while a spice with subtle taste may need larger quantities to be added.

Understand the taste and the flavour quotient of the spice you will be using as a substitute before you add to balance the taste.

2.  Using fresh spice substitute instead of powder

Sometimes similar flavour can be derived from using fresh ingredients such as onions, ginger, garlic or fresh herbs.

Not all spices can be substituted with another spice. When you do use fresh ingredients, you are likely to use them less in quantity to the dish to balance the required taste.

3. The quantity you are cooking

We do have a tendency to overlook the proportion of the number of heads we are cooking for when following a recipe.

The quantity of raw material used should represent the number of people you are making the dish for.

Ensure that the amount of raw material to spice replacement is in proportion.

4. Health and personal reasons to look for suitable alternatives

Few may also need to look for spice substitute because of an eating lifestyle, intolerance/allergy or simply a personal dislike to a particular spice.

Having the alternatives and substitute works in their favour so that they do not have to compromise on the taste or try the dish.

It is a good idea to choose alternatives which suit your purpose.

A List of Best Alternative Spice Substitute For Popular Indian Spices

Keeping the tips of substituting spices while retaining the originality of the recipes, here is a list of spice substitutes for some of the most commonly used spices.

Thanks to the convenience of online shopping, you can easily buy the original spices in a  click.

I have made it even easier for you to buy the spices just by clicking on the images in the table below:

Name of Spice Type and Usage Substitute Option 1 Substitute Option 2

Substitute for Asafoedita 

Asafoedita-image- hing-image buy Indian spices online Spiceitupp

 

It is a gun resin with a very strong flavour. Use sparingly in dishes. Onion and Garlic powder Shallots, Fresh Garlic or leeks

Substitute for   Cardamom 

green- cardamom-elaichi-image-indian-spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Floral, citrusy with robust flavour. A very popular spice in Indian dishes Cinnamon and Cloves Cinnamon and nutmeg (just a pinch)

Substitute for Caraway Seeds

Caraway - seeds - shahi -jeera -image buy indian-spices-online spiceitupp

Belongs to the cumin seeds family, mild and sweet in flavour Roasted cumin seeds Dill

Substitute for Carom Seeds

ajwain-seeds-carom-seeds-whole buy-spices-online - Spiceitupp

Similar to caraway seeds with liquorice undertones Dried Thyme Roasted cumin seeds

Substitute for Chat Masala

Amchur_powder- dry -mango -powder-image buy Indian spices online Spiceitupp

A street food seasoning that is sour in taste Dry mango powder/Lemon juice Sumac powder

Substitute for Chilli powder

red -chilli-indian-chilli -powder-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Spice that renders heat and sometimes colour to the dish  Omit from the dish or use paprika Green chilli/ pepper powder

Substitute for Cinnamon

cinnamon-cassia-sticks-dalchini buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Woody smoky undertones used in savoury and sweet dishes Nutmeg/Allspice  Mace

Substitute for  Cloves

Nelken-ganz-Gewuerzland-com-2 Cloves7 Buy Spices online Switzerland

 

A bud with a robust strong flavour Nutmeg/Allspice Cinnamon

Substitute for Coriander leaves

fresh -coriander leaves-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Fresh herb added for extra depth of freshness to the dish Omit completely

A small mix of Parsley, tarragon and dill leaves

 

Substitute for Coriander powder

Popular ground spice with a mild taste Cumin powder – If not already used in the dish Curry powder

Substitute for Cumin Powder

Ground- cumin-powder-image-jeera -powder-indian-spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Mild ground spice to add taste to the dish Coriander powder – If not already used in the dish Curry powder

Substitute for Fresh Curry Leaves 

Indian- fresh-curry -leaves-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

A very important Indian herb with a lemony flavour Lemon zest Kaffir lime leaves

Substitute for Curry Powder 

Indian-curry-powder-image-indian-spice-blend. buy Indian spices online spiceit upp

 

 

Popular Indian spice blend made with different ground spices Garam Masala powder  A mix of coriander powder, cumin powder and turmeric

Substitute for Fennel Seeds

Fennel- seeds-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Liquorice in taste. Adds a distinctive flavour to the dish Dill Star Anise/ caraway seeds

Substitute for Fenugreek Seeds

fenugreek- seeds -methi-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

A popular whole spice used in many Indian dishes. Has a slight bitter tone. Mustard seeds Curry powder

Substitute for Fresh Ginger

Fresh-ginger-paste-indian-cooking buy online

A popular aromatic used for making sweet and savoury dishes Ginger powder Allspice powder

Substitute for Garam Masala

Indian- garam- masala-powder-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Popular Indian spice blend used in most Indian spices. Curry powder Allspice and cumin

Substitute for Mace

Mace-whole-javitri-image-indian-spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Robust and strong pungent spice. Use sparingly in the dish. Nutmeg Allspice

Substitute for Mustard paste

mustard-powder- for-mustard-paste-indian-spice Buy Indian mustard paste online

Pungent and sharp. introduces heat and smoothness to a dish Dijon mustard sauce A small portion of horseradish or wasabi paste

Substitute for Mustard Seeds 

whole-mustard-seeds-image-indian-spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Normally used as a tempering or pickling spice Caraway seeds Nigella Seeds

Substitute for Nutmeg

nutmeg -whole-jaiphal-indian-spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Strong yet delicately flavoured spice with a sweet woody tone  Mace Cinnamon

Substitute for Poppy Seeds

white-poppy-seeds-khus-khus-indian-spice image buy indian spices online spiceitupp

Used whole or as a paste to give texture to the dish Chia seeds Melon seeds (for paste only)

Substitute for Pomegranate seeds

Pomegranate-seeds-anardana-indian-spice-buy indian spices online spice it upp

 

Souring agent to add tartness to dish Sumac powder Lemon juice

Substitute for Saffron

saffron-spice-image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

A flavouring and colouring agent with a strong sweet taste Rose essence and turmeric Cardamon

Substitute for Star Anise

star anise image buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Woody and earthy it adds a distinctive flavour to the dish Chinese five spice powder Cinnamon/ fennel seeds/ Aniseed

Substitute for Turmeric

turmeric-powder-haldi-image-indian-yellow -spice buy indian spice online spiceitupp

Mainly used as a colouring agent to give the dish a yellow appearance Tomato paste Curry powder

 

Indian spice substitute for difficult to find spices

 

Experiment with the substitute before you say No

A way of understanding if you like a recipe or a particular substitute or not, is by giving it a try.

Before you give up on making a dish because you do not have a particular ingredient, I would suggest finding a suitable alternative.

You will realise that the alternative does the job as long as you follow the rules of replacement mentioned above.

Start with a substitute you think is the best match.

Trying new combinations will widen your culinary skills making your kitchen life so much easier.

It may not work each time but from my personal experience of using substitutes, I can guarantee that it will not be catastrophic as long as you have the right balance of taste and correct amount used.

Use the list above as a starting point as most of the substitute mentioned are easily available in your local supermarket.

Here is a pinnable image with the list of Indian spice substitute for your instant reference.

A useful list of Indian Spices with their best spice substitute when you find it hard to find the Indian spices. Do not stop yourself from making an Indian recipe when you struggle to find specific Indian spices. Use this spice chart for a quick reference to cook your favorite Indian curry. #justspices #indianfoodblogger #spicelist #indianspicelist #substituteforcardamom # substituteforchatmasala #spicesubstitute #cookingwithspices #spicepantry #foodofindia #tasteofindia #spiceologist #spiceitupp #indianfoodtips

I have made it easy for you to embed the above infographic on best substitute spices. Simply copy and paste the code below to your website.

Will be very grateful if you credited my website for the supplied info.

Share this Image On Your Site

Do you have any spice substitute

Spices are indeed a flexible cooking ingredient to work with which makes them easy to either omit or replace if needed.

What are some of the alternatives or food substitutes you have tried using? It’s always so good to learn from each other.

And if you think that the post and the spice substitute list will help others then I would really appreciate a share by clicking the share or save button below.